Comments on: Mummepoll Ballot http://smartfootball.com/blogpoll/mummepoll-ballot Analysis and strategy by Chris. Wed, 08 Feb 2012 18:51:00 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Chris http://smartfootball.com/blogpoll/mummepoll-ballot/comment-page-1#comment-1556 Chris Mon, 12 Oct 2009 19:26:14 +0000 http://smartfootball.com/?p=553#comment-1556 I fixed the South Carolina thing. That was a mistake. I fixed the South Carolina thing. That was a mistake.

]]> By: am19psu http://smartfootball.com/blogpoll/mummepoll-ballot/comment-page-1#comment-1554 am19psu Mon, 12 Oct 2009 19:15:28 +0000 http://smartfootball.com/?p=553#comment-1554 Assuming Chris just copied and pasted the output from the poll (maybe not a good one?), I figured he had Cincy in the Top 5, whereas I put in VT. That's what I meant by flip. Assuming Chris just copied and pasted the output from the poll (maybe not a good one?), I figured he had Cincy in the Top 5, whereas I put in VT. That’s what I meant by flip.

]]> By: cerebral http://smartfootball.com/blogpoll/mummepoll-ballot/comment-page-1#comment-1553 cerebral Mon, 12 Oct 2009 18:52:34 +0000 http://smartfootball.com/?p=553#comment-1553 If you look at the poll several people are picking tcu and boise as top 5... also i think this way of voting makes more sense. cept for the idiots who put san jose st and UTEP top 5 last week. am19psu, the order doesnt matter with this poll... here are my top 12 top 5: florida alabama texas miami Va Tech next 7: usc lsu boise st oregon ohio state cincinnati tcu virginia tech If you look at the poll several people are picking tcu and boise as top 5… also i think this way of voting makes more sense. cept for the idiots who put san jose st and UTEP top 5 last week. am19psu, the order doesnt matter with this poll…

here are my top 12
top 5:
florida
alabama
texas
miami
Va Tech

next 7:
usc
lsu
boise st
oregon
ohio state
cincinnati
tcu
virginia tech

]]> By: am19psu http://smartfootball.com/blogpoll/mummepoll-ballot/comment-page-1#comment-1548 am19psu Mon, 12 Oct 2009 17:35:40 +0000 http://smartfootball.com/?p=553#comment-1548 Did you mean Southern Cal instead of South Carolina? Otherwise, our only difference is flipping Cincy and VT. Did you mean Southern Cal instead of South Carolina? Otherwise, our only difference is flipping Cincy and VT.

]]> By: Rob http://smartfootball.com/blogpoll/mummepoll-ballot/comment-page-1#comment-1547 Rob Mon, 12 Oct 2009 17:32:45 +0000 http://smartfootball.com/?p=553#comment-1547 The biggest problem with the Mumme Poll system is that it is impossible for certain teams to do well in it. Boise St and TCU (this year) and Utah (last year) will always be undervoted because some people refuse to accept a non-BCS conference team as being a top team. No one rational would leave Alabama out of the top 12. However, I dont see any rational reason to not have Boise St in the top 12 right now either. The biggest problem with the Mumme Poll system is that it is impossible for certain teams to do well in it. Boise St and TCU (this year) and Utah (last year) will always be undervoted because some people refuse to accept a non-BCS conference team as being a top team.

No one rational would leave Alabama out of the top 12. However, I dont see any rational reason to not have Boise St in the top 12 right now either.

]]>